TFC
Read the storyline of The Furry Conflict Hear the audio drama version of The Furry Conflict Experience parallel universes of The Furry Conflict Visit The Furry Conflict's online forums See some mentions and distinctions TFC has earned abroad Buy TFC themed clothing, cards, house wares and more
Take a look at the personal histories of some of TFC's major characters Study the alternate histories of The Furry Conflict's constitutent universes Read up on some of the more prominent planets in the galaxies of The Furry Conflict Delve into the deeper minutae of starships, technologies and interstellar government See some digital relics from the earlier years of The Furry Conflict Learn a little about the people behind The Furry Conflict and the nature of the project Browse The Furry Conflict's hyperlink library
 
 

Sublight Engine Performance: USS Enterprise: Solar System Exit Analysis

Event Context: Star Trek: The Motion Picture. A mysterious cloud of alien origin and unknown intent is on course for the planet Earth. Observations of the cloud's activity reveal that it has already destroyed a trio of Klingon starships. Concerned, StarFleet dispatches the newly refitted USS Enterprise to investigate and address the possible threat. But the cloud is closing on Earth quickly and the Enterprise's new warp engines have yet to be fully tested. Captain Kirk puts off engaging the warp drive for 1.8 hours, instead relying on impulse to get the ship about as far as Jupiter.
 
     
 
Star Wars vs. Star Trek: TFC Argumentative Repository
Article Category : General Event Analysis: Sublight Engine Performance
Date of Original Posting : October 28, 2003
Date of Latest Change :
Argumentative Status : Unchallenged
 
Please note that the articles contained within the Argumentative Repository reflect argumentative points of the writer of that article. The Furry Conflict makes no claim of correctness of these Star Wars vs Star Trek articles, but hosts them for the purposes of review, records and debate. If you take issue with a point raised in this article, we encourage you to read the Submission Guidelines and submit a reply.
 
     
 

Article Originally Submitted by Marc Xavier

 
     
 
The Constitution-class starship is one of the most recognizable ships of the Federation's starfleet and is a definitive symbol for the "Star Trek" franchise. This article deals with the performance of one of the most famous starships of this class, the refitted USS Enterprise, in the first Star Trek feature film: Star Trek: The Motion Picture.

Impulse drive is the propulsion system that many ships in Star Trek use to get around while inside solar systems and traveling below the speed of light (termed "sublight propulsion"). Though this propulsion system commonly takes a back seat to the more prominent warp drive (which normally moves ships faster than light), it is nonetheless an impressive technology with capabilities that are often taken for granted in the grand scheme of interstellar space travel.

In comparison to the distances which separate the stars, the distance between the planets in the solar system can seem quite negligible, but in comparison to even the most extended modern human journeys, they are not. This article should help to better illustrate the still-vast distances between planets that orbit the sun, as well as how impulse drive has been used to deal with traversing them.

The newly refitted Enterprise waits in drydock above Earth

There is a basic timeline to consider which is illustrated in The Motion Picture that begins when the Enterprise is first launched from drydock above Earth (about 32 minutes into the movie if you wish to follow along). In this timeline, there are five key events to consider:

1. 2. 3. 4. 5.  
 
Leaving Drydock
 
Leaving Orbit
 
Engage Impulse
 
En Route
 
Arrival at Jupiter
 
     
  Scotty: "Intermix set, bridge. Impulse power at your discretion."
  Kirk: "Impulse power, Mr. Sulu. Ahead warp 0.5."

According to the National Space Science Data Center, the distance between Earth and Jupiter varies from about 968 million kilometers (maximum) to 588 million kilometers (minimum); anywhere from about 1,529 to 2,518 times the distance from the Earth to the moon.

Given these distances, deriving a range of how fast (on average) the Enterprise was moving from Earth to Jupiter would also require a measure of the time it took to cross this distance. One possible way to find a value would be to look at screen time; literally how much time passed between the shot where the Enterprise is shown leaving Earth and the shot where it is seen flying past Jupiter. But movies often take artistic liberty with the passage of time for the sake of keeping the audience interested or to enhance a sense of suspense or drama. Fortunately for us, in this instance Captain Kirk himself provides a value:

  Kirk: "Captain's Log, stardate 7412.6; 1.8 hours from launch. In order to intercept the intruder at the earliest possible time, we must now risk engaging warp drive while still within the solar system."

Shortly after passing Jupiter, there is a voiceover of Captain Kirk making an entry in his log. He describes their current situation and also gives the audience a time value of how long they've been traveling inside of the Solar System: 1.8 hours, or 108 minutes. This makes it possible to derive a range of speeds the Enterprise would have to be moving at in order to reach Jupiter in the time allotted.

Average Velocity can be derived by the following formula:
Average velocity = Distance / Time

If Jupiter were it's closest to Earth, the distance would be about 588,500,000 kilometers; the time would be about 108 minutes, or about 6,480 seconds. This works out to an average velocity of about 90,818 kilometers per second, or about 1/3 the speed of light.

If Jupiter were it's farthest from Earth, the distance would be about 968,100,000 kilometers; the time would still be about 6,480 seconds. This works out to an average velocity of about 149,398 kilometers per second, or about 1/2 the speed of light.

That's extremely fast, but still sublight; all of this occurred before Kirk decided to risk engaging the warp drive (which resulted in a wormhole accident because of an engine imbalance).

 

Want to submit a response to this article? Read the Submission Guidelines.

 

Star Trek vs Star Wars - The Furry Conflict™
[ BIOGRAPHIES | TIMELINES | LOCATIONS | TECHNOPEDIA | MEDIA | ABOUT | LINKS ]

[ STORYLINE | AUDIO DRAMA | BACKSTAGE | FAN FICTION | COMMUNITY | PRESS | MERCHANDISE ]
 

 
Star Trek™ & Star Wars™ are © Paramount Pictures and Lucasfilm LTD, respectively. THE FURRY CONFLICT™ and all related original material © 1999-2004 Julius Harper II. All Rights Reserved. All original characters and their distinctive likenesses are © their original creators. All other content contained herein, unless otherwise noted, is © its original creators. THE FURRY CONFLICT™ is a parody and creative critique protected under the terms and laws of Fair Use; no copyright infringement is intended by anything on these pages. Do not re-post, redistribute, or reproduce anything contained herein without permission from the original creators. [ Credits | Terms of Use ]